What Drives Managers and Leaders to Choose the Path of Rudeness

I have always been curious about what drives managers and leaders to choose the path of rudeness. It’s perplexing how they can perceive this behavior as an enabler for performance and delivery.
Some leaders may believe that rudeness instills urgency or discipline within their teams, thinking that a tough approach pushes employees to meet deadlines and achieve goals.
However, research reveals a different reality.
A study published in the Journal of Business and Psychology found that workplace incivility leads to decreased job performance and increased employee disengagement.
– Specifically, employees who experience rudeness are 30% more likely to withdraw from their work and reduce their overall productivity.
Additionally, a survey by the Harvard Business Review showed that
– 48% of employees reported witnessing rudeness at work
– Those who did were 66% less likely to feel committed to their organization. This suggests that rudeness not only demotivates individuals but also erodes the overall culture of teamwork and collaboration, which are crucial for high performance.
Moreover, research from the University of Massachusetts indicates that leaders who model respectful behavior create a positive ripple effect, fostering a work environment where employees feel valued and empowered. This, in turn, leads to higher engagement, lower turnover and improved performance outcomes.
In contrast to the belief that rudeness drives results, the evidence strongly supports that respect and empathy are far more effective in enhancing productivity and team dynamics.
I’m eager to explore this phenomenon further and understand how we can shift the narrative in leadership to prioritize kindness and professionalism, ultimately leading to greater success & wellbeing for everyone involved.

Global certified leadership & executive coach and accredited facilitator of transformation.